By Aleesha Mary Joseph
Consider a 2*2 pure exchange economy (ie 2 goods & 2 consumers).
The endowments are – Individual 1 (8,8)
Individual 2 (2,2).
Utility functions are as follows:
(1) Individual 1 has lexicographic preferences with respect to X. That is
The bundle (x1 , y1) will be preferred to (x2 , y2) when x1>x2.
But if x1=x2, then the bundle (x1 , y1) will be preferred to (x2 , y2) if and only if y1>y2.
(2) Individual 2’s utility function is given by U(x,y) = x^2 + y^2
Now our task is to find the contract curve and the competitive equilibrium.
SOLUTION
(I) CONTRACT CURVE
First convince yourself that we cannot construct indifference curve (IC) for individual 1’s preferences. Because there are no 2 distinct bundles between which individual 1 will be indifferent.
Now let’s figure out how 2nd individual’s IC looks like.
For example let’s plot IC that represents 4 utils. Ie x^2 + y^2 = 4. Note that this is actually the equation of a circle centered at (0,0), with radius 2. Also since we are bothered about only positive values of x & y, IC representing 4 utils will be represented as follows:
Now let us put
everything in our edgeworth box as in the following figure(please google or
refer any standard microeconomic textbook if you don’t know what an edgeworth
box is). The dark point represents the endowment.
Now let us find the pareto efficient points. Pick any IC of individual 2 (say the red one). Now consider the point A. If we move along the IC in the direction given by the arrows, then individual 1 is getting better off and individual 2 is not getting worse. Hence the point A is not pareto efficient. Using the same logic we can argue out that there is only 1 pareto efficient point along the red IC and that is B. Now convince yourself using the same argument that all the points along O1B and BO2 are pareto efficient. Hence the contract curve is O1B and BO2.
(II) COMPETITIVE EQUILIBRIUM
Notations : X11 – quantity of good 1 demanded by individual 1
X12 – quantity of good 2 demanded by individual 1
X21 – quantity of good 1 demanded by individual 2
X22 – quantity of good 2 demanded by individual 2
Mi - Income of individual i.
First of all let us write down the demand function for individual 1
(X11, X12) = (M1/P1 , 0) { Because for individual 1 only consumption of good 1 matters. }
The demand function for individual 2 is derived using the same logic as mentioned in the previous file (similar to the max function in the file).
(X21, X22) = (M2/P1 , 0) when P1 / P2 < 1
(M2/P1 , 0) or (0, M2/P2) when P1 / P2 = 1
(0, M2/P2) when P1 / P2 > 1
Normalize P2 = 1.
Now,
Since individual 1’s endowment is (8,8), income of individual 1 M1 = 8P1 + 8.
Since individual 2’s endowment is (2,2), income of individual 1 is M2 = 2P1 + 2.
Note that since individual 1 consumes only good 1, all of good 2 has to be consumed by individual 2.
Hence from individual 2’s demand given above, it is clear that P1 / P2 has to be greater than or equal to 1. Since P2 is normalized, P1 ≥ 1.
Note that the budget line should pass through the endowment.
CASE I
Suppose the budget line is the green line given below.
On extending the green line we get the following figure:
Convince yourself that:
• The extended green line is the budget line faced by individual 1.
• Given this budget line, individual 1 will consume the bundle P.
• This implies that in the economy there will be excess demand for good 1 as individual 1’s consumption is outside the edgeworth box.
CASE II
Suppose the budget line is the RED line given below.
On extending the red line we get the
following figure:
Convince yourself that:
• The extended RED line is the budget line faced by individual 2.
• Given this budget line, individual 2 will consume the bundle Q.
• This implies that in the economy there will be excess demand for good 2 as individual 2’s consumption is outside the edgeworth box.
CASE III
Suppose the budget line is the BLUE line given below.
Convince yourself that when the budget line
is the blue line, it is optimal for both individuals 1 and 2 to consume the
bundle B. Hence the price ratio associated
with the blue line will be the competitive equilibrium price ratio.
Since (8,8) is the coordinate of the black dot and (10,0) is the coordinate of
B, the euilibrium price ratio P1/P2 = 4.
From the above three cases note that
competitive equilibrium can occur only in the third case and in the other 2
cases markets do not clear.
On summarising, competitive equilibrium
allocation is (10,0) for individual 1 and (0,10) for individual 2 with
competitive equilibrium price ratio being
4.
(Aleesha Mary Joseph graduated from St. Stephen's College in 2013. She is currently pursuing MA in Economics at Delhi School of Economics)
Similar question as this was asked in this year's ISI entrance.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteExcellent and very cool idea and the subject at the top of magnificence and I am happy to this post..Interesting post! Thanks for writing it. What's wrong with this kind of post exactly? It follows your previous guideline for post length as well as clarity..
ReplyDeleteDataware Housing Training in Chennai
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletenice post!!!i really enjoyed that and i got more information's from your post.thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletecloud computing training in chennai
I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. This information is impressive. I am inspired with your post.. I hope you post again soon. photos very nice.
ReplyDeleteJava Training in Chennai
Thanks for sharing this information...
ReplyDeleteInterior Designers in Chennai
Interiors in Chennai
Good Interior Designers in Chennai
Nice blog.Very useful information.Thank you.
ReplyDeleteTop Interior Decorators in Chennai
Top 10 Interior Decorators in Chennai
I do believe all of the concepts you’ve introduced in your post. They’re very convincing and will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are too short for novices. May you please extend them a bit from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.
ReplyDeleteManufacturing ERP
RFID Solutions
Athletic Management Software
Logistics management software
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAmazing Article ! I have bookmarked this article page as i received good information from this. All the best for the upcoming articles. I will be waiting for your new articles. Thank You ! Kindly Visit Us @ Coimbatore Travels | Ooty Travels | Coimbatore Airport Taxi | Coimbatore taxi | Coimbatore Taxi
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your efforts because it conveys the message of what you are trying to say. It's a great skill to make even the person who doesn't know about the subject could able to understand the subject . Your blogs are understandable and also elaborately described. I hope to read more and more interesting articles from your blog. All the best.
ReplyDeleteData Science course in rajaji nagar
Data Science with Python course in chenni
Data Science course in electronic city
Data Science course in USA
Data science course in pune | Data Science Training institute in Pune
Data science course in bangalore
Thank you for sharing this interesting article with us. I'd like to learn more about this position. We'd like to share our article with you Right Click CPS Test The right-click CPS test is used all throughout the world for a variety of reasons. Gamers check the mouse-click indications on a frequent basis to improve their game skills.
ReplyDeleteTo get instant support for QuickBooks problems, dial QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number+1 855-444-2233. Our team makes sure to provide you with the best-in-class technical service for QuickBooks at a reasonable rate.
ReplyDeleteIf you are looking for reliable after-sales service in Mumbai, you may have come to the right place. Dell is a multinational company that produces computer monitors, laptops, and other electronic devices. With a number of centers located across the country, you can get your laptop or computer repaired without the need for a lengthy wait. Moreover, a Dell service center offers pickup and shipment of your laptop or computer.
ReplyDeletedell service center near me Mumbai
There are many benefits of finding an HP service center near me. HP values customer feedback and is dedicated to providing the highest level of customer service. You can use HP's service center finder to find an HP repair center near you. You can also find out what's open and close to your home or office, and how to get there. HP service centers are available across the U.S. and India. Just enter your zip code to find the nearest center.
ReplyDeleteHp service center near me
Get Your Own Tea Cafe Franchise in India
ReplyDeleteFood franchise in India
Food franchise in india
Food franchise in India
Food franchise in India
Thanks for the post. It was very interesting and meaningful. I really appreciate it! Keep updating stuff like this.
ReplyDeletePoint cloud to 3D Model Reading
Scan to BIM in Epsom
3d Laser Scanning Services in Massachusetts
Plant Engineering Services in California
Traceability requirements matrix is a tool to document the end-to-end test case lifecycle and keep them in a single place. It helps in documenting the test cases, requirements and other details that need to be carried out during each step of the lifecycle, which includes gathering information about user requirements, what to do if any error occurs and how we plan to include other routines.
ReplyDeleteonline jobs
ReplyDeleteHiring for branch manager bhatinda location in punjab,
Hiring for backend hr profile backend operations in jammu and kashmir,
Great job, thanks for the info!
ReplyDeleteLaptop Screen Replacement Mumbai
Laptop Repair in Andheri
Laptop Repair in Bandra
Laptop Repair in Goregaon
Laptop Repair in Powai
Laptop Repair in Malad
Laptop Repair in Wadala
Laptop Battery Replacement Mumbai
After a Long search, I found this post and I must say that this post worth my research and provide me all knowledge and clears my confusion of choosing the solved assignments of nmims
ReplyDeleteAwesome Blog! Thanks for sharing this post. It is a nice post. When I read about this blog then got more information.
ReplyDeleteecommerce web design kent
SEO company in kent
digital marketing company kent
web design company in kent london
Software development kent
web design kent london
고양콜걸
ReplyDelete거창콜걸
고양콜걸
일산콜걸
파주콜걸
합천콜걸
과천콜걸
과천콜걸
how can i find used injection molds for sale in my area please guide me
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful post it really helps me a lot to learn new things keep doing .
ReplyDeletepower-bi-training-in-hyderabad